Chris said:
I can't agree with that in the slightest bit.
I have to agree with Thomas. I too was offended by Roedy's signature. I
know Roedy well enough to know his political views, but usually he tries
to separate it out.
As long as Roedy is
posting on-topic content in this newsgroup, his signature is his
business.
I disagree. Just because he posts good stuff does not give him a free
ride to do what he pleases. Roedy has wasted the group's time with
off-topic political rants in the past (and almost caused Patricia to
throw a temper tantrum ;-). See this thread about his conspiracy theory
about 9/11 where he claims the govt. was lying about how many deaths
there were:
<
http://groups-beta.google.com/group...read/thread/d989547983ee72f3/500e988037fc655a>
Let me take a quote from that thread that I think fits this situation
perfectly:
"Roedy, why are you doing this? I know that you know better. I have a
lot of respect for what you've done for a lot of the Java newcomers in
this group and for the tremendous Java programming resource you can
provide, but that does *not* give you the right to spam the group with a
conspiracy theory...that doesn't relate to Java. People who
are interested can follow this subject in other ways, using their own
choices of information sources."
Do you know who wrote those words to Roedy 4 1/2 years ago, Chris?? YOU DID!
There is nothing verbally abusive in Roedy's signature.
Baloney! Accusing the president of war crimes is not considered abusive
or offensive?
Flame wars are not the fault of someone expressing an idea that you
don't like (which is, after all, a vital and indispensable part of
actually participating in society), but rather someone who gets out of
hand in responding to it.
I strongly object to the idea that newsgroups need to be sterile and
isolated from the world, as if we were getting automatic responses from
intelligent machines instead of talking to real people who care about
real events and relationships.
Roedy's politically charged offensive signature has no business here.
This is a group about Java programming and that is what posts should be
about. Posting crap that is only meant to be offensive does not belong
here. That kind of stuff is *meant* to incite a flame war. I give Thomas
credit for not flaming Roedy, but asking him politely to take the hate
speech somewhere else.
The issue is about being on-topic not being sterile. Sometimes the group
will drift into off-topic political discussions. We understand that. It
is another thing entirely to repeatedly post offensive stuff that
encourages that.