# how to extract LaTeX macro arguments?

Discussion in 'Perl' started by ivo welch, Dec 23, 2003.

1. ### ivo welchGuest

I know regex can't do this, so may I ask what the recommended
procedure is for extracting a bracketed TeX argument, which itself can
contain other bracketed TeX arguments?

$string = " text \sometexmacro{arg1}{this is a second {\bf arg} argument} more text"; and file.pm has a sub that makes it easy to describe all the arguments to sometexmacro \sometexmacro arg1: 'arg1' arg2: 'this is a second {\bf arg} argument' if it were even smarter, it could also handle TeX comments and escapes, such as file.tex: \sometexmacro{arg1}{this is a second %} {\bf arg} argument, which handles \} correctly } Life would be heaven if regex's could do this, because I could then automatically replace the second argument with what I want it to be. Alas, they cannot. will they be able to do this in perl6? ivo welch, Dec 23, 2003 1. ### Advertisements 2. ### Gunnar HjalmarssonGuest ivo welch wrote: > I know regex can't do this, Do you? Please show us the code that made you jump at that incorrect conclusion. Preferrably a small program that people can run. > so may I ask what the recommended procedure is for extracting a > bracketed TeX argument, which itself can contain other bracketed > TeX arguments? I'd say that a Perl regular expression would be fine. <random code fragments snipped> > Life would be heaven if regex's could do this, Then life _is_ heaven! Isn't that wonderful? -- Gunnar Hjalmarsson Email: http://www.gunnar.cc/cgi-bin/contact.pl Gunnar Hjalmarsson, Dec 23, 2003 1. ### Advertisements 3. ### ivo welchGuest how about an example (if this is possible) then? ivo welch, Dec 25, 2003 4. ### Gunnar HjalmarssonGuest ivo welch wrote: > how about an example (if this is possible) then? Nope. I think people should give it a serious try to solve their problems themselves before asking for help in this and similar groups, and you have in no way indicated that you have tried yourself. On the contrary, considering the way you asked, I'd bet that you are just trying to have other people do the job for you. You know, this is not a "we write your code for free" service. It's a Usenet group for discussing the Perl programming language. Maybe I should add: This group is defunct, and replaced by comp.lang.perl.misc. If I was wrong above, and if you want to ask for help there, I do recommend that you reconsider your posting style. -- Gunnar Hjalmarsson Email: http://www.gunnar.cc/cgi-bin/contact.pl Gunnar Hjalmarsson, Dec 25, 2003 5. ### ivo welchGuest Thanks for the hint. I had looked at the perlfaq6, Can I use Perl regular expressions to match balanced text? Although Perl regular expressions are more powerful than "mathematical" regular expressions, because they feature conveniences like backreferences (\1 and its ilk), they still aren't powerful enough -- with the possible exception of bizarre and experimental features in the development-track releases of Perl. You still need to use non-regex techniques to parse balanced text, such as the text enclosed between matching parentheses or braces, for example. and I had tried to play with the feature, but I could not figure it out. I think short one-liner examples fall well within the "please help" category and not just into the "do the programming for me" category. regards, /iaw Gunnar Hjalmarsson <> wrote in message news:<xuJGb.43658$>...
> ivo welch wrote:
> > how about an example (if this is possible) then?

>
> Nope. I think people should give it a serious try to solve their
> problems themselves before asking for help in this and similar groups,
> and you have in no way indicated that you have tried yourself. On the
> contrary, considering the way you asked, I'd bet that you are just
> trying to have other people do the job for you.
>
> Usenet group for discussing the Perl programming language. Maybe I
> should add: This group is defunct, and replaced by comp.lang.perl.misc.
>
> If I was wrong above, and if you want to ask for help there, I do
> recommend that you reconsider your posting style.

ivo welch, Dec 26, 2003