Performance and Scalability of JSP and ASP

[tharma]

I was wondering if some one provides some information about scalability
and performance of ASP vs JSP.

Scalability of JSP vs. ASP (which one is better?)

Performance of JSP vs. ASP (which has better performance?)

I have been looking for graphs, and charts that compare JSP vs. ASP
(scalability and performance) but I couldn't find any. If anyone knows
any link which has scalability of performance graph of ASP vs. JSP,
please let me know.

 

[Travis Newbury]

I was wondering if some one provides some information about scalability
and performance of ASP vs JSP.....

A quick google for "Performance comparison of JSP and ASP" resulted in
a plethora of information.

 

[SpaceGirl]

I was wondering if some one provides some information about scalability
and performance of ASP vs JSP.

Scalability of JSP vs. ASP (which one is better?)

Performance of JSP vs. ASP (which has better performance?)

I have been looking for graphs, and charts that compare JSP vs. ASP
(scalability and performance) but I couldn't find any. If anyone knows
any link which has scalability of performance graph of ASP vs. JSP,
please let me know.

From experience; While JSP (java) is more scalable, it is a LOT slower
than ASP on similar hardware. I dont think there is a black and white
answer - it totally depends what you are doing. ASP may be faster at
some things, and JSP may be faster at other things. You also dont make
clear what versions you are talking about. ASP.NET is very scalable,
whereas regular ASP is not quite so object-orientated so that limits you
a bit. Java is very object-orientated, but has a lot of layers to it
which can slow development and execution down in some cases.

--


x theSpaceGirl (miranda)

# lead designer @ http://www.dhnewmedia.com #
# remove NO SPAM to email, or use form on website #
# this post (c) Miranda Thomas 2005
# explicitly no permission given to Forum4Designers
# to duplicate this post.

 

[Dylan Parry]

Using a pointed stick and pebbles, SpaceGirl scraped:

Java is very object-orientated, but has a lot of layers to it
which can slow development and execution down in some cases.

Back when I was learning Java, I was told that it is approximately 100x
slower than C equivalent due to the "virtual machine" execution style. I
don't know how this compares with ASP.NET though, as that has a similar
execution style.

 

[Neredbojias]

With neither quill nor qualm, Travis Newbury quothed:

A quick google for "Performance comparison of JSP and ASP" resulted in
a plethora of information.

Yes but dharma's not interested in plethoras; she wants performance and
I can't say that I blame her...

 

[Jim Higson]

Using a pointed stick and pebbles, SpaceGirl scraped:


Back when I was learning Java, I was told that it is approximately 100x
slower than C equivalent due to the "virtual machine" execution style. I
don't know how this compares with ASP.NET though, as that has a similar
execution style.

100x is a pretty big exaggeration. Modern JVMs have just-in-time
compilation, so they're really running native machine code for the most
often used bits (badly optimised native code, but at least not directly
interpreted byte code)

IME good Java takes about 1.5 to 3 times what good C++ would. It depends
what you're doing of course, if the ap is heavily dependant on a database
that might be the bottleneck anyway.