D
David MacQuigg
I am writing a chapter for teaching OOP in Python. This chapter is
intended as a brief introduction to replace the more complete
discussion in Learning Python, 2nd ed, pp. 295-390. I need to explain
instance variables.
What I'm looking for is the best compromise between brevity and a full
explanation. The students are non-CIS technical professionals (
engineers and scientists ). At the point they need this explanation,
they have covered functions and modules, but not classes. They are
new to object-oriented programming. They have just been shown a class
definition with some data attributes and methods.
The non-CIS background is important, because I can't assume any
experience with other computer languages.
I would like to hear from users who have a similar background, or
anyone who has taught such users. What is your background? Which of
the alternatives below do you like or dislike? Can you think back on
your own learning experience, and write something better?
Here are some alternatives I have collected:
1) Python Tutorial at http://docs.python.org/tut/node11.html
------------------------------------------------------------
What exactly happens when a method is called? You may have noticed
that x.f() was called without an argument above, even though the
function definition for f specified an argument. What happened to the
argument? Surely Python raises an exception when a function that
requires an argument is called without any -- even if the argument
isn't actually used...
Actually, you may have guessed the answer: the special thing about
methods is that the object is passed as the first argument of the
function. In our example, the call x.f() is exactly equivalent to
MyClass.f(x). In general, calling a method with a list of n arguments
is equivalent to calling the corresponding function with an argument
list that is created by inserting the method's object before the first
argument.
If you still don't understand how methods work, a look at the
implementation can perhaps clarify matters. When an instance
attribute is referenced that isn't a data attribute, its class is
searched. If the name denotes a valid class attribute that is a
function object, a method object is created by packing (pointers to)
the instance object and the function object just found together in an
abstract object: this is the method object. When the method object is
called with an argument list, it is unpacked again, a new argument
list is constructed from the instance object and the original argument
list, and the function object is called with this new argument list.
2) comp.lang.python 4/27/04, David MacQuigg
-------------------------------------------
Some of the variables inside the methods in a class have a self.
prefix. This is to distinguish local variables in the method from
"instance variables". These instance variables will be found when the
method is called, by searching the instance which called the method.
The way this works is that calling the method from an instance causes
that instance to be passed as the first argument to the method call.
So if you call cat1.talk(), that is equivalent to Cat.talk(cat1) If
you call cat1.set_vars( "Garfield", "Meow"), that is equivalent to
Cat.set_vars(cat1, "Garfield", "Meow")
The "current instance" argument is automatically inserted as the first
argument, ahead of any other arguments that you may provide in calling
a method that is "bound" to an instance. Note: The distinction
between instances and classes is important here. If you call a method
from a class, that method is not bound to any instance, and you have
to supply the instance explicitly in the first argument (
Cat.talk(cat1) )
The variable name self is just a convention. As long as you put the
same name in the first argument as in the body of the definition, it
can be self or s or even _ The single underscore is handy if you
want to maximally suppress clutter.
3) comp.lang.python 4/27/04, Greg Ewing
---------------------------------------
When a function is called from an instance (e.g. cat1.talk()), the
instance is passed in as an extra parameter at the beginning of the
parameter list, conventionally named 'self'. This allows you to refer
to attributes of the instance as 'self.attrname' (e.g. self.sound).
=====================================
Thanks for your help on this project.
-- Dave
************************************************************* *
* David MacQuigg, PhD * email: dmq at gain.com * *
* IC Design Engineer * phone: USA 520-721-4583 * * *
* Analog Design Methodologies * * *
* * 9320 East Mikelyn Lane * * *
* VRS Consulting, P.C. * Tucson, Arizona 85710 *
************************************************************* *
intended as a brief introduction to replace the more complete
discussion in Learning Python, 2nd ed, pp. 295-390. I need to explain
instance variables.
What I'm looking for is the best compromise between brevity and a full
explanation. The students are non-CIS technical professionals (
engineers and scientists ). At the point they need this explanation,
they have covered functions and modules, but not classes. They are
new to object-oriented programming. They have just been shown a class
definition with some data attributes and methods.
The non-CIS background is important, because I can't assume any
experience with other computer languages.
I would like to hear from users who have a similar background, or
anyone who has taught such users. What is your background? Which of
the alternatives below do you like or dislike? Can you think back on
your own learning experience, and write something better?
Here are some alternatives I have collected:
1) Python Tutorial at http://docs.python.org/tut/node11.html
------------------------------------------------------------
What exactly happens when a method is called? You may have noticed
that x.f() was called without an argument above, even though the
function definition for f specified an argument. What happened to the
argument? Surely Python raises an exception when a function that
requires an argument is called without any -- even if the argument
isn't actually used...
Actually, you may have guessed the answer: the special thing about
methods is that the object is passed as the first argument of the
function. In our example, the call x.f() is exactly equivalent to
MyClass.f(x). In general, calling a method with a list of n arguments
is equivalent to calling the corresponding function with an argument
list that is created by inserting the method's object before the first
argument.
If you still don't understand how methods work, a look at the
implementation can perhaps clarify matters. When an instance
attribute is referenced that isn't a data attribute, its class is
searched. If the name denotes a valid class attribute that is a
function object, a method object is created by packing (pointers to)
the instance object and the function object just found together in an
abstract object: this is the method object. When the method object is
called with an argument list, it is unpacked again, a new argument
list is constructed from the instance object and the original argument
list, and the function object is called with this new argument list.
2) comp.lang.python 4/27/04, David MacQuigg
-------------------------------------------
Some of the variables inside the methods in a class have a self.
prefix. This is to distinguish local variables in the method from
"instance variables". These instance variables will be found when the
method is called, by searching the instance which called the method.
The way this works is that calling the method from an instance causes
that instance to be passed as the first argument to the method call.
So if you call cat1.talk(), that is equivalent to Cat.talk(cat1) If
you call cat1.set_vars( "Garfield", "Meow"), that is equivalent to
Cat.set_vars(cat1, "Garfield", "Meow")
The "current instance" argument is automatically inserted as the first
argument, ahead of any other arguments that you may provide in calling
a method that is "bound" to an instance. Note: The distinction
between instances and classes is important here. If you call a method
from a class, that method is not bound to any instance, and you have
to supply the instance explicitly in the first argument (
Cat.talk(cat1) )
The variable name self is just a convention. As long as you put the
same name in the first argument as in the body of the definition, it
can be self or s or even _ The single underscore is handy if you
want to maximally suppress clutter.
3) comp.lang.python 4/27/04, Greg Ewing
---------------------------------------
When a function is called from an instance (e.g. cat1.talk()), the
instance is passed in as an extra parameter at the beginning of the
parameter list, conventionally named 'self'. This allows you to refer
to attributes of the instance as 'self.attrname' (e.g. self.sound).
=====================================
Thanks for your help on this project.
-- Dave
************************************************************* *
* David MacQuigg, PhD * email: dmq at gain.com * *
* IC Design Engineer * phone: USA 520-721-4583 * * *
* Analog Design Methodologies * * *
* * 9320 East Mikelyn Lane * * *
* VRS Consulting, P.C. * Tucson, Arizona 85710 *
************************************************************* *