Jim Langston said:
Actually, you did effect the final outcome. Because if you don't answer
their question they may just decide to try to figure it out and actually
learn something, reguardless of the grade they get. By answering their
question without them using their own grey matter you may have made it so
they don't learn anything.
Perhaps, yes. On the other hand, if they decide to try and figure it out and
fail, they may learn nothing, whereas if they try and understand an answer
they've been given they may learn something. The bottom line in my view is
that if they're serious about learning, you might as well help them, because
even if you have to give them the answer this time they'll read it and
understand it and be able to do it next time (we hope). If they don't try
and understand it and just hand it in, then so be it, since they probably
wouldn't have tried to figure it out on their own anyway if they're not
really interested in the answer.
On a more conciliatory note, I do appreciate why it's not considered a good
idea to give people answers to exercises. But being a student myself I know
that sometimes there's nothing like the answer to help you understand a
problem. If you're interested enough in what you're doing then getting the
answer to a problem you were stuck on can be really useful. Obviously if you
just want the answer so you can have some free time then you're not going to
get much out of being given the answer, but then again you're probably not
getting much out of your course so there's no real harm being done, in a
sense.
Whilst you can certainly say that giving some people the answer will mean
they won't think about a problem, it's also true that some people will still
think about it and, what's more, they'll have more to base their thinking
on. Sometimes you can spend ages banging your head against a brick wall if
you're not really sure what's going on and when you see the answer you can't
understand why you didn't get it before. Having the answer to a question
allows you to see if you can understand how to get from one to the other.
There are lots of different ways of learning, but I personally find worked
solutions tend to help me understand things. (Obviously you have to read
them to get anything out of the whole experience, but just because not
everyone does doesn't mean that providing solutions is necessarily a bad
idea.)
Anyway, this is beginning to get a little off-topic, so I think I'll say for
the record that I respect your viewpoint and other than that let's agree to
disagree because we're just going to go round in circles
And because I've
just had the horrifying realisation that I've written several paragraphs on
this and I don't think either of us is interested enough in the outcome to
justify that sort of verbiage!
Regards,
Stu