UDP Socket problem

[Shannon Fang]

Hi there,

I try to write a comm program based on udp broadcasting protocol. I did the
following:

SERVER:

require 'socket'
server = UDPSocket.open
server.bind('0.0.0.0', 4321)
while true do
p server.recvfrom(10)
end

CLIENT

require 'socket'
socket = UDPSocket.open
socket.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
socket.send("sample", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)

Now there are 2 problems:

1) the server will print out 2 line of data e.g.:
["sample", ["AF_INET", 1339, "XRFANG-OTM", "192.168.1.101"]]
["sample", ["AF_INET", 1339, "XRFANG-OTM", "192.168.1.101"]]

but the client only sent one packet.

2) if the client send data more than 10 bytes, the server will crash! I
don't know how to set the "recvfrom" so that it can receive ANY byte of
data. i.e. when the client supplied more than the maximum wanted data for
the server, the rest should be received on the next call to recvfrom, or at
least, it should simply discard the excessive data, it must not crash the
server anyway.

Thank you very much!

Shannon

 

[ts]

I can't reproduce

S> CLIENT

moulon% ruby
require 'socket'
socket = UDPSocket.open
socket.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
socket.send("sample", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)
socket.send("1234567890123456789012345678901234567890123456789012345678901234567890", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)
moulon%


S> SERVER

moulon% ruby
require 'socket'
server = UDPSocket.open
server.bind('0.0.0.0', 4321)
while true do
p server.recvfrom(10)
end
["sample", ["AF_INET", 47842, "moulon.inra.fr", "138.102.114.1"]]
["1234567890", ["AF_INET", 47842, "moulon.inra.fr", "138.102.114.1"]]
^C
-:5:in `recvfrom': Interrupt
from -:5
moulon%


Guy Decoux

 

[Shannon Fang]

I run the program on winxp, is that causing problems???

I will test on linux, if anything interesting I will report.

thanks,
shannon

From: ts <[email protected]>
Reply-To: (e-mail address removed)
To: (e-mail address removed) (ruby-talk ML)
CC: (e-mail address removed)
Subject: Re: UDP Socket problem
Date: Fri, 25 Nov 2005 00:58:55 +0900


I can't reproduce

S> CLIENT

moulon% ruby
require 'socket'
socket = UDPSocket.open
socket.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
socket.send("sample", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)
socket.send("1234567890123456789012345678901234567890123456789012345678901234567890",
0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)
moulon%


S> SERVER

moulon% ruby
require 'socket'
server = UDPSocket.open
server.bind('0.0.0.0', 4321)
while true do
p server.recvfrom(10)
end
["sample", ["AF_INET", 47842, "moulon.inra.fr", "138.102.114.1"]]
["1234567890", ["AF_INET", 47842, "moulon.inra.fr", "138.102.114.1"]]
^C
-:5:in `recvfrom': Interrupt
from -:5
moulon%


Guy Decoux

 

[Shannon Fang]

Hi,

I have tested this on my linux, it worked fine, but this problem do exist on
both win2k (pro.) and winxp (home).

Any ideas?

thanks a lot!
shannon

From: ts <[email protected]>
Reply-To: (e-mail address removed)
To: (e-mail address removed) (ruby-talk ML)
CC: (e-mail address removed)
Subject: Re: UDP Socket problem
Date: Fri, 25 Nov 2005 00:58:55 +0900


I can't reproduce

S> CLIENT

moulon% ruby
require 'socket'
socket = UDPSocket.open
socket.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
socket.send("sample", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)
socket.send("1234567890123456789012345678901234567890123456789012345678901234567890",
0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)
moulon%


S> SERVER

moulon% ruby
require 'socket'
server = UDPSocket.open
server.bind('0.0.0.0', 4321)
while true do
p server.recvfrom(10)
end
["sample", ["AF_INET", 47842, "moulon.inra.fr", "138.102.114.1"]]
["1234567890", ["AF_INET", 47842, "moulon.inra.fr", "138.102.114.1"]]
^C
-:5:in `recvfrom': Interrupt
from -:5
moulon%


Guy Decoux

 

[Joel VanderWerf]

Hi there,

I try to write a comm program based on udp broadcasting protocol. I did
the following:

SERVER:

require 'socket'
server = UDPSocket.open
server.bind('0.0.0.0', 4321)
while true do
p server.recvfrom(10)
end

CLIENT

require 'socket'
socket = UDPSocket.open
socket.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
socket.send("sample", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321)

Now there are 2 problems:

1) the server will print out 2 line of data e.g.:
["sample", ["AF_INET", 1339, "XRFANG-OTM", "192.168.1.101"]]
["sample", ["AF_INET", 1339, "XRFANG-OTM", "192.168.1.101"]]

but the client only sent one packet.

Can't reproduce that. Does it happen repeatably? Does it happen if you do
server.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
after opening the server socket?

I'm on WinXP, with ruby-1.8.2 from the installer.

2) if the client send data more than 10 bytes, the server will crash! I
don't know how to set the "recvfrom" so that it can receive ANY byte of
data. i.e. when the client supplied more than the maximum wanted data
for the server, the rest should be received on the next call to
recvfrom, or at least, it should simply discard the excessive data, it
must not crash the server anyway.

I see that too:

server.rb:6:in `recvfrom': A message sent on a datagram socket was
larger than the internal message buffer or some other network limit, or
the buffer used to receive a datagram into was smaller than the datagram
itself. - recvfrom(2) (Errno::EMSGSIZE)
from server.rb:6

That doesn't seem like winsock has correctly implemented UDP. Shouldn't
recvfrom discard extra bytes?

Googling for "winsock udp broadcast" shows that others have found
similar problems. Particularly:

http://forum.java.sun.com/thread.jspa?threadID=680096&messageID=3972638

I guess this means the receiver needs to (a) know the max size of
legitimate data and (b) handle EMSGSIZE (at least logging an error, but
maybe not exiting).

Useful to know. Thanks!

 

[Yuri Kozlov]

yuray@yuray:~/r$ ruby --version
ruby 1.8.2 (2004-12-25) [i686-linux]
yuray@yuray:~/r$ cat c.rb
require 'socket'
socket = UDPSocket.open
socket.setsockopt(Socket::SOL_SOCKET, Socket::SO_BROADCAST, true)
socket.send("sample1234567890", 0, '255.255.255.255', 4321) ### more
then 10

yuray@yuray:~/r$
yuray@yuray:~/r$ cat s.rb
require 'socket'
server = UDPSocket.open
server.bind('0.0.0.0', 4321)
while true do
p server.recvfrom(10)
end

yuray@yuray:~/r$ ruby s.rb
["sample1234", ["AF_INET", 32783, "yuray.####.ru.", "172.20.1.33"]]

Works for me. Client and server was running on single machine.
What is ruby version?
Can you run the test client and server on single machine?
Can you test with a new clear ruby installation without any packages ?

Regards,
Yuri Kozlov

 

[Shannon Fang]

This problem confirmed to be a winsock problem, not ruby's. tks! btw, I run
ruby 1.8.2 on winxp.

shannon