Gateway broken?

[Berger, Daniel]

Hi all,

It appears that messages posted to google groups are not making it the
ML again.

Can we please fix? Thanks.

Dan

 

[Dennis Oelkers]

Hey folks,

Yep, it sure is broken. I'm also getting some sort of bounce messages?

If you supply me with some msg-ids and/or subjects, I will investigate
it, and check if there really
is a problem at the gateway.
Anyway: the gateway does not send bounce messages of any kind to anyone.

Kind regards,
Dennis Oelkers

 

[James Edward Gray II]

If you supply me with some msg-ids and/or subjects, I will investigate
it, and check if there really is a problem at the gateway.

The gateway has been one way for several days now. A quick trip to
Google Groups shows it well. I had a lot of trouble with this during
this weeks Ruby Quiz. Here's the two submissions that never came to
the mailing list:

http://groups-beta.google.com/group/comp.lang.ruby/msg/65a71c96a50491e3

and

http://groups-beta.google.com/group/comp.lang.ruby/msg/3bcab05c47d47bc6

Anyway: the gateway does not send bounce messages of any kind to
anyone.

I too am seeing this odd behavior, whatever the cause.

James Edward Gray II

 

[Joel VanderWerf]

Hey folks,

If you supply me with some msg-ids and/or subjects, I will investigate
it, and check if there really
is a problem at the gateway.
Anyway: the gateway does not send bounce messages of any kind to anyone.

Kind regards,
Dennis Oelkers

One example: the recent thread on "priority queue using RBTree". My
posts to the list went to the list and ng. The reply from Arah Howard
was not forwarded to the list (I only found out about it because he
addressed it to me as well).

Thanks!

 

[Dennis Oelkers]

Hey James,

I too am seeing this odd behavior, whatever the cause.

It would be helpful if you (or anyone else receiving any bounces) would
forward them
to me (keeping all headers as they are), so I can check out if they
really originate at the
gateway.

Kind regards,
Dennis Oelkers

 

[Hal Fulton]

Hey James,



It would be helpful if you (or anyone else receiving any bounces) would
forward them
to me (keeping all headers as they are), so I can check out if they
really originate at the
gateway.

I've seen this -- my impression has been that it's a symptom of
the mailing list itself.


Hal

 

[James Edward Gray II]

I think I may have deleted all the bounces, I'll take a look. They're
coming from a japanese qmail server that states the message has been
in the queue for too long, To: my ruby-ml address. I don't think that
I have return receipts turned on or anything.

To be clear though, these messages ARE showing up on the mailing list,
then I get a bounce notice days later.

James Edward Gray II

 

[Martin DeMello]

To be clear though, these messages ARE showing up on the mailing list,
then I get a bounce notice days later.

That sounds more like someone has subscribed to the list with an address
that went invalid, his host is sending a bounce message, and the mailing
list is configured such that the sender's email address goes in the
reply-to.

martin

 

[Dennis Oelkers]

I've seen this -- my impression has been that it's a symptom of
the mailing list itself.

Yes, those bounces are definitely not related to the gateway at all.
I guess they result from a subscribes broken mta which is using the
return-path to send the bounce to the original posted instead of the
mailing list host.

Kind regards,
Dennis Oelkers

 

[James Edward Gray II]

If you supply me with some msg-ids and/or subjects, I will investigate
it, and check if there really is a problem at the gateway.

Any word on the status of the gateway? Thanks.

James Edward Gray II

 

[Dave Burt]

Any word on the status of the gateway? Thanks.

James Edward Gray II

No quiz posts have been sent to c.l.r but not the ML yet.
I see three solutions both ways:
- Matthew Moss
- Glenn Parker
- Dave Burt

 

[ts]

J> Any word on the status of the gateway?

Apparently it's unidirectional : work only ruby-talk ==> clr

See for example the thread

"[newby] class variables and class instance variable?"

on google


Guy Decoux

 

[Dennis Oelkers]

Hey ts, hey list,

J> Any word on the status of the gateway?

Apparently it's unidirectional : work only ruby-talk ==> clr

See for example the thread

"[newby] class variables and class instance variable?"

on google

You are absolutely right, due to the fact that I was out of office
for a few days, I didn't notice that I had left the script in "do nothing,
just log what you would you" debugmode, stupid me!

Nonetheless, all missing postings from the group should reach the
list in the next minutes.

Kind regards (and sorry!),
Dennis Oelkers

 

[ES]

Hey ts, hey list,

J> Any word on the status of the gateway?

Apparently it's unidirectional : work only ruby-talk ==> clr

See for example the thread

"[newby] class variables and class instance variable?"

on google

You are absolutely right, due to the fact that I was out of office
for a few days, I didn't notice that I had left the script in "do nothing,
just log what you would you" debugmode, stupid me!

Nonetheless, all missing postings from the group should reach the
list in the next minutes.

Indeed they did, unfortunately in some arbitrary semi-inverse order

Kind regards (and sorry!),
Dennis Oelkers

No problem, thanks for the service!

E