fop or itext for java to pdf generation

Tim (archive)

Usenet Archive
Joined
Jan 24, 2000
Messages
770
Reaction score
0
Hi

Can anyone comment on the pros and cons of fop (using xml) or itext (java lib) for generating pdfs from a java programme. My requirements are to produce a "glossy" hi-fidelity brochure type pdf of approx 50 pages in length. The source data for the report will be pulled out of a database and will consist of text and graphics. I need to be able to use page numbering and use a "table of contents" in the pdf.

Are there other tools suitable for doing this. I don't mind paying for the right product,

Any help appreciated,

Tim
 

Ingo R. Homann

Usenet Archive
Joined
Apr 28, 2005
Messages
457
Reaction score
0
Hi Tim,
Can anyone comment on the pros and cons of fop (using xml) or itext (java lib) for generating pdfs from a java programme. My requirements are to produce a "glossy" hi-fidelity brochure type pdf of approx 50 pages in length. The source data for the report will be pulled out of a database and will consist of text and graphics. I need to be able to use page numbering and use a "table of contents" in the pdf.

Are there other tools suitable for doing this. I don't mind paying for the right product,

I didn't use FOP really (I only tried it and it somehow did seem unsuitable to me), but I am using iText for quite a while.

I think, iText will work for what you want to do, although a table of contents is a bit tricky and concerning this, there are some disadvantages, IIRC (I think, the number of pages reserved for the table of contents has to be fixed in advance or something like that).

Further disadvantages of iText are:
- No RowSpan for PdfPTables (IIRC, normal Tables can do Rowspan, but they have some other disadvantages too (Borders?))
- No relative sizes esepcially for images and tables (absolute to relative widths and heights have to be calculated manually)
- weak support for page breaks / no-page-break

As you see, the disadvantages are only important when you want to do "advanced" things.

At all, I think, iText is a very good package when you want to generate PDFs.

Ciao,
Ingo
 

Raymond DeCampo

Usenet Archive
Joined
Aug 1, 2003
Messages
502
Reaction score
0
Tim said:
Hi

Can anyone comment on the pros and cons of fop (using xml) or itext (java lib) for generating pdfs from a java programme. My requirements are to produce a "glossy" hi-fidelity brochure type pdf of approx 50 pages in length. The source data for the report will be pulled out of a database and will consist of text and graphics. I need to be able to use page numbering and use a "table of contents" in the pdf.

Are there other tools suitable for doing this. I don't mind paying for the right product,

The TeX or LaTeX systems, available on many Unix systems (I think MikTeX is Windows) is designed for creating such complex documents. Knuth wrote the original TeX so that he could create his classic textbooks.

Ray
 

Andrew (25)

Usenet Archive
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Hi Tim,

Tim said:
Can anyone comment on the pros and cons of fop (using xml) or itext (java lib) for generating pdfs from a java programme. My requirements are to produce a "glossy" hi-fidelity brochure type pdf of approx 50 pages in length. The source data for the report will be pulled out of a database and will consist of text and graphics. I need to be able to use page numbering and use a "table of contents" in the pdf.
Are there other tools suitable for doing this. I don't mind paying for the right product,

I've used Apache FOP for doing something similar to what you describe - producing (shorter) glossy flyers dynamically. My experience suggests that using XSL:FO allows you to have a much finer-grained control over the layout and presentation of your PDF output than a tool like iText can provide. Think things like text leading, kerning, font sizes, colourings, indentation, page and area margins etc.

Having said that, bear in mind that Apache FOP does not currently implement the full scope of XSL:FO capabilities (<http://xml.apache.org/fop/compliance.html> has more details of what the current implementation of FOP does support). You'll need to decide whether it's missing any key areas of functionality that you think you'll need for your project. If it is lacking, there are much more feature-complete commercial XSL:FO engines available, but of course these cost significant $$$.

Page numbering is very easy with FOP. I haven't created anything more than a simple table of contents, but they are certainly part of the XSL:FO spec, and at least some support is implemented in FOP (but beware of memory limitation issues if you have a large document and lots of forward references, which a table of contents implicitly requires).

Overall, I was very satisfied with XSL:FO and FOP. Occassionally I had to creatively work around some limitations, but these were more in the category of minor hassles than major headaches or showstoppers.

Good luck with the project!

Cheers,
Andrew
 

Steve Sobol

Usenet Archive
Joined
Aug 26, 2004
Messages
540
Reaction score
0
Andrew said:
I've used Apache FOP for doing something similar to what you describe - producing (shorter) glossy flyers dynamically. My experience suggests that using XSL:FO allows you to have a much finer-grained control over the layout and presentation of your PDF output than a tool like iText can provide. Think things like text leading, kerning, font sizes, colourings, indentation, page and area margins etc.

It's wonderful. http://JustThe.net/legal/tos/ contains a form whose target is a Java servlet that takes the information from the form, plugs it into the appropriate places in an XML template, and renders it all via XSL:FO (and FOP). Only thing is, it's a tad sluggish (note that my web page says 10-15 seconds to render the page). But other than that, it works *really* well. And FO does allow you a good bit of control over what goes where.
Page numbering is very easy with FOP. I haven't created anything more than a simple table of contents, but they are certainly part of the XSL:FO spec, and at least some support is implemented in FOP (but beware of memory limitation issues if you have a large document and lots of forward references, which a table of contents implicitly requires).

I can offer some source code if people are interested :)
 

Thomas Weidenfeller

Usenet Archive
Joined
May 25, 2000
Messages
1,555
Reaction score
0
Raymond said:
The TeX or LaTeX systems, available on many Unix systems (I think MikTeX is Windows) is designed for creating such complex documents. Knuth wrote the original TeX so that he could create his classic textbooks.

TeX is available for almost every OS. If the OP is looking for some native Unix formatter/typesetter, than that would be troff plus some troff macro library. The GNU version of troff - groff - has been ported to an number of non-Unix platforms, too, including Windows.

Early versions of troff were written in (PDP-11?) assembler, later ones in C. groff is written in C++.

/Thomas
 

Tim (archive)

Usenet Archive
Joined
Jan 24, 2000
Messages
770
Reaction score
0
thanks for the info. It looks like there hasn't been a realse of fop for sometime. I'm a little concerned that the project has "ground to a halt". Anyone know if a new release is likely soon?

Tim
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
548,049
Messages
3,104,245
Members
248,133
Latest member
DujonT

Latest Threads

Top