Xalan using generic DOM structures..

[Ganesh Gella]

Hi All,

I am planning to use Xalan to transform XML data by applying xls stylesheets.

Here tricky part is, Xalan provides several C++ APIs, which are very much useful if our requirement is just inputting a file and getting a file. Or giving a xerces dom and get a new xerces dom.

I would like to know whether any of you tried with their own custom made DOM structures and used Xalan to transform them ?

I would like to know, is there any way, by which one of the methods like transform throw SAX events by which we can build our DOM structures ? And in the same way input also using SAX events. (insteas of taking certain formatted DOMs and returning fixed DOM structures).

If any of you tried Xalan for such requirements, I request you to throw some pointers on this topic. I appreciate your help in this regards.

Thanks
Ganesh

 

[Tjerk Wolterink]

Hi All,

I am planning to use Xalan to transform XML data by applying xls stylesheets.

Here tricky part is, Xalan provides several C++ APIs, which are very much useful if our requirement is just inputting a file and getting a file. Or giving a xerces dom and get a new xerces dom.

I would like to know whether any of you tried with their own custom made DOM structures and used Xalan to transform them ?

I would like to know, is there any way, by which one of the methods like transform throw SAX events by which we can build our DOM structures ? And in the same way input also using SAX events. (insteas of taking certain formatted DOMs and returning fixed DOM structures).

If any of you tried Xalan for such requirements, I request you to throw some pointers on this topic. I appreciate your help in this regards.

Thanks
Ganesh

I do not really understand your question.

You want XML to be transformed with an XSL to an other XML format?
is that right?

Xalan can do the transformation process for you,
i do not see what the problem is.

I think you mean, you want to have some control over the transformation process, am i right?

Give an example please.

 

[Ganesh Gella]

Hi,

Thanks for your reply.
Let me try to explain the problem in some detail now.

Yes, my intention is to xonvert one XML document to another using XLS. And Xalan has some C++ APIs for it.

Xalan accepts a xml file, a stream and a xerces dom object also (using parserliason,domsupport classes) as an input and gives the result in XSLTResultTarget class.

Here my problem is, our code is already having it's own DOM object (different from xerces DOM) which is constructed based on SAX events.

I wanted to know how to plug-in this DOM object to Xalan's transform methods so that I can use it's transform capabilities.

It has built-in methods to transform, xerces doms, I wanted to know is there any way we can plug in our own DOM objects and get the output in may be xerces dom or in the same format that we need.

Or in other words, my question can be phrased like this,

Do xalan transform methods always require a already built-in DOM objects ? Can transform methods accept SAX events ? such that it itself creates the dom and throws us resultant sax events ? (Once it throws the sax events, we can build our own DOM (like xerces DOM).

Your inputs and ideas are highly appreciated in this regard.

Thanks and Regards
Ganesh Gella

 

[Ganesh Gella]

Hi,

Thanks for your reply.
Let me try to explain the problem in some detail now.

Yes, my intention is to xonvert one XML document to another using XLS. And Xalan has some C++ APIs for it.

Xalan accepts a xml file, a stream and a xerces dom object also (using parserliason,domsupport classes) as an input and gives the result in XSLTResultTarget class.

Here my problem is, our code is already having it's own DOM object (different from xerces DOM) which is constructed based on SAX events.

I wanted to know how to plug-in this DOM object to Xalan's transform methods so that I can use it's transform capabilities.

It has built-in methods to transform, xerces doms, I wanted to know is there any way we can plug in our own DOM objects and get the output in may be xerces dom or in the same format that we need.

Or in other words, my question can be phrased like this,

Do xalan transform methods always require a already built-in DOM objects ? Can transform methods accept SAX events ? such that it itself creates the dom and throws us resultant sax events ? (Once it throws the sax events, we can build our own DOM (like xerces DOM).

Your inputs and ideas are highly appreciated in this regard.

Thanks and Regards
Ganesh Gella

 

[Tjerk Wolterink]

Hi,

Thanks for your reply.
Let me try to explain the problem in some detail now.

Yes, my intention is to xonvert one XML document to another using XLS. And Xalan has some C++ APIs for it.

I'm not excellent C++ programmer,
but i know java well, and object oriented design principles, so i think i can help.

Xalan accepts a xml file, a stream and a xerces dom object also (using parserliason,domsupport classes) as an input and gives the result in XSLTResultTarget class.

Here my problem is, our code is already having it's own DOM object (different from xerces DOM) which is constructed based on SAX events.

Ok, so: you have your own Node classes?
Your own Element classes?

Is that right?

I wanted to know how to plug-in this DOM object to Xalan's transform methods so that I can use it's transform capabilities.

Well, if you have your own Dom (Node, Element,Attribute) classes then that is impossible *i think*.

Unless:

first, why do you have your own Dom classes?
Probably to give some extended functionality.

But if you want to give Dom classes extended functionality, you should subclass the XalanNode classes [ XalanElement etc] wich you want to have more functionality.

It has built-in methods to transform, xerces doms, I wanted to know is there any way we can plug in our own DOM objects and get the output in may be xerces dom or in the same format that we need.

Then *i think* you can transform it using Xalan XSLT processor. You get a Xerces dom in return.

Or in other words, my question can be phrased like this,

Do xalan transform methods always require a already built-in DOM objects ? Can transform methods accept SAX events ? such that it itself creates the dom and throws us resultant sax events ? (Once it throws the sax events, we can build our own DOM (like xerces DOM).

I do not know much about events in xalan, so i cant help you there.

 

[David Bertoni]

Hi,

Thanks for your reply.
Let me try to explain the problem in some detail now.

Yes, my intention is to xonvert one XML document to another using XLS. And Xalan has some C++ APIs for it.

Xalan accepts a xml file, a stream and a xerces dom object also (using parserliason,domsupport classes) as an input and gives the result in XSLTResultTarget class.

Here my problem is, our code is already having it's own DOM object (different from xerces DOM) which is constructed based on SAX events.

I wanted to know how to plug-in this DOM object to Xalan's transform methods so that I can use it's transform capabilities.

Take a look at how the Xerces-C DOM is wrapped by looking at the "wrapper" classes in the XercesParserLiaison source directory. However, it's not a trivial undertaking, that's for sure. If your "DOM" is close to a standard DOM, you can probably do a "cut-and-paste" approach, and have your wrapper working pretty quickly.

It has built-in methods to transform, xerces doms, I wanted to know is there any way we can plug in our own DOM objects and get the output in may be xerces dom or in the same format that we need.

Or in other words, my question can be phrased like this,

Do xalan transform methods always require a already built-in DOM objects ? Can transform methods accept SAX events ? such that it itself creates the dom and throws us resultant sax events ? (Once it throws the sax events, we can build our own DOM (like xerces DOM).

Xalan-C will either use its default source tree implementation, which you can build by parsing a source file with the parser, or through sending your own SAX2 events. See the DocumentBuilder sample for more information on how you can do that. Xalan-C always works best with its default source tree implementation, which is optimized for XSLT. Xalan-C always builds the entire tree into memory.

As for output, take a look at what you can provide to the constructor of XSLTResultTarget. One of those things is a class called FormatterListener, which is like a SAX DocumentHandler. If you want the output as events, you can create your own derivative of that, and do what you want with the events.

Your inputs and ideas are highly appreciated in this regard.

You should consider joining one of the Xalan-C mailing list and posting your questions there. You will get far faster and more detailed replies there.

Dave

 

[Ganesh Gella]

Hi Dave,

Thanks for your reply. On the output side it is some what clear to me on how to move ahead. As you said, creating a new calss(in similare lines of FormatterToXercesDOM) that implements FormatterListener is the way to go.

Then my new class can be given to the constructor of XSLTResultTarget.

I will try to implement this and see how far I can get through.

On the input side, I am still having doubts on how I can pump the events to xalan and ask it to do the transform from there on..

Let me first start with creating FormatterLister like class and then get back to you with further questions.

Thanks
Ganesh

 

[Ganesh Gella]

Hi All,

I started exploring on the output side and creating my own DOM structure using Xalan's transform method.

As discussed in the group before, I am depending on XSLTResultTarget class for this. This class accepts a FormatterToXercesDOM class in its constructor. FormatterToXercesDOM is derived from an abstract class FormatterLister, which is a class derived from DocumentHandler.

So here I created a new class that is derived from FormatterListener and passes on the events to another clas that is derived from ContentHandler. (The existing parser in my code is derived from ContentHandler).

Here I came across following problem,

all parsers that derive from DocumentHandler are using AttributeList objects and all those who derive from ContentHandler are using Attributes class. The major difference is, Attributes does not have URI,QName explicitely.

Now I need to bridge AttributeList class to Attributes class. I would like to know whether any of you worked on a similar problem before and have some clues on converting attributelist class to attributes ?

Any pointers and help is highly appreciated.

Thanks
Ganesh

Hi,

Thanks for your reply.
Let me try to explain the problem in some detail now.

Yes, my intention is to xonvert one XML document to another using XLS. And Xalan has some C++ APIs for it.

I'm not excellent C++ programmer,
but i know java well, and object oriented design principles, so i think i can help.

Xalan accepts a xml file, a stream and a xerces dom object also (using parserliason,domsupport classes) as an input and gives the result in XSLTResultTarget class.

Here my problem is, our code is already having it's own DOM object (different from xerces DOM) which is constructed based on SAX events.

Ok, so: you have your own Node classes?
Your own Element classes?

Is that right?

I wanted to know how to plug-in this DOM object to Xalan's transform methods so that I can use it's transform capabilities.

Well, if you have your own Dom (Node, Element,Attribute) classes then that is impossible *i think*.

Unless:

first, why do you have your own Dom classes?
Probably to give some extended functionality.

But if you want to give Dom classes extended functionality, you should subclass the XalanNode classes [ XalanElement etc] wich you want to have more functionality.

It has built-in methods to transform, xerces doms, I wanted to know is there any way we can plug in our own DOM objects and get the output in may be xerces dom or in the same format that we need.

Then *i think* you can transform it using Xalan XSLT processor. You get a Xerces dom in return.

Or in other words, my question can be phrased like this,

Do xalan transform methods always require a already built-in DOM objects ? Can transform methods accept SAX events ? such that it itself creates the dom and throws us resultant sax events ? (Once it throws the sax events, we can build our own DOM (like xerces DOM).

I do not know much about events in xalan, so i cant help you there.

Your inputs and ideas are highly appreciated in this regard.

Thanks and Regards
Ganesh Gella