Sitemap & duplicate URL's

[Guest]

Does anyone know a way to allow duplicate URL's in a sitemap?

Here's my problem:

I'm designing (almost done) an online store with the following navigational
structure:

Home / Department / product listing / product detail.

Each department and product listing have unique pages but the product detail
is a single page that is given a product ID parameter in the query string.

All pages are derived from a master page which has the siteMapPath control.

What I can't do is link from the product listing page to the product detail
page and show in the siteMapPath were the user has come from i.e.:

Home / Department / Product list /product detail

I’m aware that the default sitemap provider won’t allow duplicate URL’s.

I’d be grateful for some advice!

 

[Steve C. Orr [MCSD, MVP, CSM, ASP Insider]]

You can allow a duplicate URL if you append a querystring parameter to the
end. It can be a dummy querystring parameter that doesn't do anything.
For example, the sitemap will see these as two separate pages:
Default.aspx
Default.aspx?dummy=1

 

[James Page]

You can allow a duplicate URL if you append a querystring parameter to
the end. It can be a dummy querystring parameter that doesn't do anything.
For example, the sitemap will see these as two separate pages:
Default.aspx
Default.aspx?dummy=1

Thanks Steve but there'e a problem with this work around

Say I've got the following pages:

Default.aspx, page1.aspx, page2,aspx & page3.aspx

The structure is that the default.aspx links to pages 1 & 2.aspx
Pages1 & 2 link to page3.aspx.

The sitemap =

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?>
<siteMap xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/AspNet/SiteMap-File-1.0" >

<siteMapNode url="~/default.aspx" title="Default" >
<siteMapNode url="~/page1.aspx" title="Page1">
<siteMapNode url="~/page3.aspx" title="Page 3" />
</siteMapNode>
<siteMapNode url="~/page2.aspx" title="Page2" >
<siteMapNode url="~/page3.aspx?id=2" title="Page 3" />
</siteMapNode>
</siteMapNode>
</siteMap>

A master page holds the siteMapPath.

All works fine when you link to page3 from page1 and the siteMapPath
looks like: default : Page 1 : Page 3

However when you link from page2 to page 3 the siteMapPath renders the
same as linking from page1 !

Also if you amend the first instance of page3.aspx to page3.aspx?id=1
the siteMapPath won't render at all!

I've tried all sorts of different combinations without success.

Thanks

James

 

[sureshot]

I'm having a very similar problem. Has anyone found a good solution yet?

 

[a.oveissian]

I know this is an old post but perhaps somebodyelse find my note useful;

I think master page does not make problem, but if you have pages in separate directories, may see wrong re-direction from page to page because of the current directory that system uses for search may not be root (happens after navigate to sub-directories that contain the aspx page). To avoid this:

- One of the ways is to use the complete url like following:

<siteMapNode url="http://localhost:4825/yourwebsiteFolder/default.aspx" title="Main Page" description="Main Page desc" />
or
<siteMapNode url="http://www.domain.com/default.aspx" title="Main Page" description="Main Page desc" />


- Another way is to use referrer to the root ( .. ) while addressing in sitemap:

<siteMapNode url="../subfoldername/default.aspx" title="Main Page" description="Main Page desc" />


About duplicates (I know this was not the question), parameters work, fake anchors work as well. exp: default.aspx#nowhere